Hickory Tavern Carrboro

370-110 East Main Street , Carrboro, NC 27510
Phone: 9199427417

Click Menu Item For Description

FEATURED SHOTS

$5 SHOTS

7.00

FIREBALL WHISKEY PINK WHITNEY VODKA JIM BEAM BOURBON SAUZA HACIENDA TEQUILA

$7 SHOTS

9.00

JAGERMEISTER JAMESON IRISH WHISKEY ESPOLON REPOSADO OLE SMOKY APPLE PIE MOONSHINE OLE SMO...

$9 SHOTS

11.00

PATRON SILVER TEQUILA GRAND MARNIER CASAMIGOS BLANCO TEQUILA WOODFORD RESERVE TEQUILA

DRAFT BEER

ACE Mango Cider

Sebastopol, CA

Hard Cider / 5.0% ABV

Pint ($6.50)

Angry Orchard Crisp Apple Cider

Walden, NY

Hard Cider / 5.0% ABV

Pint 250 CAL ($5.25)

Bell's Two Hearted

Kalamazoo, MI

American IPA / 7.0% ABV

Pint 280 CAL ($5.95)

Blue Moon Belgian White

Golden, CO

Belgian Wit / 5.4% ABV

Pint 220 CAL ($6.75)

Bud Light

St Louis, MO

Light Lager / 4.2% ABV

Pint 140 CAL ($5.25)

Catawba White Zombie

Morganton, NC

Witbier / 5.1% ABV

Pint 200 CAL ($5.95)

Coors Light

Golden, CO

Light Lager / 4.2% ABV

Pint 140 CAL ($5.25)

D9 Brown Sugar Brown Cow

Cornelius, NC

American Brown Ale / 6.9% ABV

Pint 260 CAL ($7.00)

Deep River 4042 Stout

Clayton, NC

Milk Stout / 6.5% ABV

Pint 240 CAL ($5.50)

Deep River Mango Tango Foxtrot

Clayton, NC

American IPA / 5.7% ABV

Pint 220 CAL ($5.50) / Tall 280 CAL ($7.00)

Dos Equis Ambar

Monterrey, MEX

Vienna Lager / 4.7% ABV

Pint 190 CAL ($5.95)

Foothills Jade IPA

Winston-Salem, NC

American Imperial IPA / 7.4% ABV

Pint 300 CAL ($6.75)

Golden Road Mango Cart

Los Angeles, CA

American Wheat Ale / 4.0% ABV

Pint 220 CAL ($5.95)

Guinness Draught

Dublin, IRL

Irish Dry Stout / 4.2% ABV

Pint 170 CAL ($6.50)

Highland Gaelic Ale

Asheville, NC

American Amber/Red Ales / 5.5% ABV

Pint 230 CAL ($6.50)

Lagunitas Hazy Wonder

Petaluma, CA

Hazy IPA / 6.0% ABV

Pint 230 CAL ($6.45)

Lagunitas IPA

Petaluma, CA

American IPA / 6.2% ABV

Pint 250 CAL ($6.50)

Lynnwood Czech Yourself

Raleigh, NC

Czech Pilsner / 5.0% ABV

Pint ($5.95)

Michelob Ultra

St Louis, MO

Light Lager / 4.2% ABV

Pint 130 CAL ($5.50)

Miller Lite

Milwaukee, WI

Light Lager / 4.2% ABV

Pint 130 CAL ($5.25)

Modelo Especial

Victor, NY

Pilsner / 4.4% ABV

Pint 190 CAL ($6.50)

Mother Earth Endless River Kolsch

Kinston, NC

Kolsch / 4.9% ABV

Pint ($5.95)

New Belgium Voodoo Ranger Agent 77 IPA

Fort Collins, CO

American IPA / 7.7% ABV

Pint ($6.45)

New Belgium Voodoo Ranger Atomic Citrus

Fort Collins, CO

American Wheat IPA / 7.0% ABV

Pint 270 CAL ($5.95)

New Belgium Voodoo Ranger Juicy Haze IPA

Fort Collins, CO

Hazy IPA / 7.5% ABV

Pint 280 CAL ($7.50)

NoDa Brewing Hop, Drop 'n Roll

Charlotte, NC

American IPA / 7.2% ABV

Pint 290 CAL ($7.25)

Red Oak Bavarian Amber Lager

Whitsett, NC

German Lager / 5.0% ABV

Pint 190 CAL ($6.45)

Samuel Adams Boston Lager

Boston, MA

Vienna Lager / 5.0% ABV

Pint 230 CAL ($6.50)

Samuel Adams Seasonal

Boston, MA

Seasonal / 0.0% ABV

Pint 200 CAL ($6.50)

Sierra Nevada Hazy Little Thing IPA

Chico, CA

Hazy IPA / 6.7% ABV

Pint 270 CAL ($7.25)

Sierra Nevada Powder Day IPA

Chico, CA

American IPA / 7.7% ABV

Pint 310 CAL ($7.00)

Sierra Nevada Sunny Little Thing

Chico, CA

American Wheat Ale / 5.0% ABV

Pint 230 CAL ($7.50)

Stella Artois

Leuven, BEL

Euro Lager / 5.0% ABV

Pint 190 CAL ($6.75)

Sweetwater 420

Atlanta, GA

American Pale Ale / 5.7% ABV

Pint 240 CAL ($5.95)

Sweetwater Blue

Atlanta, GA

American Wheat Ale / 4.9% ABV

Pint 240 CAL ($5.95)

Terrapin Luau Krunkles

Athens, GA

American IPA / 6.5% ABV

Pint 280 CAL ($5.95)

Twisted Tea Original

Cincinnati, OH

Hybrid / 5.0% ABV

Pint 280 CAL ($7.75)

White Street Merideum

Wake Forest, NC

Belgian Tripel / 9.7% ABV

High Gravity Short Pour ($4.95)

Wicked Weed Pernicious IPA

Asheville, NC

American IPA / 7.3% ABV

Pint 270 CAL ($7.50)

Wicked Weed Strawberry Kiwi Burst

Asheville, NC

Sour Ale / 4.5% ABV

Pint ($5.95)

Yuengling Traditional Lager

Pottsville, PA

American Amber Lager / 4.5% ABV

Pint 190 CAL ($4.95)

BOTTLES & CANS

Barefoot Pineapple & Passionfruit Seltzer

Modesto, CA

Hard Seltzer / 4.0% ABV

12 oz Can ($6.15)

Bell's Two Hearted

Kalamazoo, MI

American IPA / 7.0% ABV

12 oz Can 210 Cal. ($5.15)

Birdsong Jalapeno Pale Ale

Charlotte, NC

American Pale Ale / 5.5% ABV

16 oz Can ($7.00)

Blue Moon Light Sky

Golden, CO

American Wheat Ale / 4.0% ABV

12 oz Bottle 100 Cal. ($5.15)

Bold Rock Apple

Nellysford, VA

Hard Cider / 4.7% ABV

12 oz Bottle ($5.65)

Bud Light

St Louis, MO

Light Lager / 4.2% ABV

12 oz Bottle 110 Cal. ($4.50)

Bud Light Lime

St Louis, MO

Light Lager / 4.2% ABV

12 oz Bottle 110 Cal. ($5.65)

Bud Light Seltzer Variety

St Louis, MO

Hard Seltzer / 0.0% ABV

12 oz Can ($5.15)

Budweiser

St Louis, MO

American Lager / 5.0% ABV

12 oz Bottle 150 Cal. ($4.50)

Budweiser Zero

St Louis, MO

Zero Alcohol / 0.0% ABV

12 oz Can 50 Cal. ($5.15)

Coors Light

Golden, CO

Light Lager / 4.2% ABV

12 oz Bottle 100 Cal. ($4.50)

Corona Extra

Victor, NY

Pilsner / 4.6% ABV

12 oz Bottle 150 Cal. ($5.65)

Corona Light

Victor, NY

Pilsner / 4.1% ABV

12 oz Bottle 100 Cal. ($5.65)

Corona Premier

Victor, NY

Light Lager / 4.0% ABV

12 oz Bottle 90 Cal. ($5.15)

Deep River 4042 Stout

Clayton, NC

Milk Stout / 6.5% ABV

16 oz Can 240 Cal. ($6.95)

Dos Equis Ambar

Monterrey, MEX

Vienna Lager / 4.7% ABV

12 oz Bottle 150 Cal. ($5.65)

Dos Equis Lager Especial

Monterrey, MEX

Mexican Lager / 4.2% ABV

12 oz Bottle 130 Cal. ($5.65)

Elysian Contact Haze Hazy IPA

Seattle, WA

Hazy IPA / 6.0% ABV

12 oz Can 170 Cal. ($6.75)

Founders All Day IPA

Grand Rapids, MI

American IPA / 4.7% ABV

12 oz Bottle 140 Cal. ($6.15)

Heineken

Amsterdam, NLD

Euro Lager / 5.0% ABV

12 oz Can 140 Cal. ($5.65)

Heineken 0.0

Amsterdam, NLD

Zero Alcohol / 0.0% ABV

12 oz Bottle 80 Cal. ($5.15)

High Noon Hard Seltzer Variety Pack

Modesto, CA

Hard Seltzer / 4.5% ABV

12 oz Can ($8.45)

Highland Oatmeal Porter

Asheville, NC

American Porter / 5.8% ABV

12 oz Bottle 190 Cal. ($5.65)

Lagunitas A Little Sumpin' Sumpin' Ale

Petaluma, CA

American IPA / 7.5% ABV

12 oz Can 230 Cal. ($5.65)

Lagunitas Hazy Wonder

Petaluma, CA

Hazy IPA / 6.0% ABV

12 oz Can 170 Cal. ($5.65)

Lagunitas IPNA

Petaluma, CA

Non-Alcoholic / 0.5% ABV

12 oz Can 80 Cal. ($5.65)

Michelob Ultra

St Louis, MO

Light Lager / 4.2% ABV

12 oz Bottle 100 Cal. ($5.15)

Michelob Ultra Pure Gold

St. Louis, MO

American Lager / 3.8% ABV

12 oz Bottle 90 Cal. ($5.65)

Miller High Life

Milwaukee, WI

American Lager / 4.6% ABV

16 oz Can 190 Cal. ($4.50)

Miller Lite

Milwaukee, WI

Light Lager / 4.2% ABV

12 oz Bottle 100 Cal. ($4.50)

New Belgium Fat Tire Ale

Fort Collins, CO

American Golden Ale / 5.0% ABV

12 oz Bottle 160 Cal. ($5.65)

New Belgium Voodoo Ranger Juice Force Hazy Imperial IPA

Fort Collins, CO

American Imperial IPA / 9.5% ABV

12 oz Can 240 Cal. ($5.15)

Newcastle Brown Ale

Newcastle, GBR

English Brown Ale / 4.7% ABV

12 oz Bottle 130 Cal. ($5.15)

NoDa Lil Slurp

Charlotte, NC

Hazy IPA / 6.0% ABV

16 oz Can ($5.65)

Omission Pale Ale

Portland, OR

American Pale Ale / 5.8% ABV

12 oz Bottle 180 Cal. ($5.65)

Oskar Blues Dale's Pale Ale

Longmont, CO

American Pale Ale / 6.5% ABV

12 oz Can 200 Cal. ($5.65)

Pabst Blue Ribbon

Los Angeles, CA

American Lager / 4.8% ABV

16 oz Can 190 Cal. ($4.00)

Rolling Rock Amber Lager

St Louis, MO

American Amber Lager / 4.0% ABV

12 oz Bottle ($4.00)

Samuel Adams Just the Haze

Boston, MA

Non-Alcoholic / 0.5% ABV

12 oz Bottle ($5.65)

Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

Chico, CA

American Pale Ale / 5.6% ABV

12 oz Can 180 Cal. ($5.15)

Sol

Monterrey, MEX

American Lager / 4.5% ABV

12 oz Bottle 140 Cal. ($5.15)

Stella Artois

Leuven, BEL

Euro Lager / 5.0% ABV

12 oz Bottle 150 Cal. ($4.65)

Sweetwater 420

Atlanta, GA

American Pale Ale / 5.7% ABV

12 oz Can 180 Cal. ($5.15)

Tecate

Monterrey, MEX

American Pale Lager / 4.0% ABV

12 oz Can 140 Cal. ($4.50)

Twisted Tea Original

Cincinnati, OH

Hybrid / 5.0% ABV

12 oz Can 210 Cal. ($4.65)

Vizzy Hard Seltzer Varity Pack

Chicago, IL

Hard Seltzer / 5.0% ABV

12 oz Can 100 Cal. ($5.65)

White Claw Hard Seltzer Variety Pack

Chicago, IL

Hard Seltzer / 5.0% ABV

12 oz Can 100 Cal. ($5.15)

Yuengling Traditional Lager

Pottsville, PA

American Amber Lager / 4.5% ABV

12 oz Bottle 140 Cal. ($4.50)

SIGNATURE COCKTAILS

Hickory Tavern Old Fashioned

13

Knob Creek Rye, Brown Sugar, Bitters, Orange Peel and a Cherry

Blackberry Maker's Smash

12

Maker’s Mark Bourbon, Triple Sec, Lemon Juice & Blackberry Puree

5 Mules

11

Choice of Tito’s Vodka, Maker’s Mark Bourbon, Milagro Silver Tequila, Hendrick’s Gin or Jameso...

Hickory Island Tea

11

New Amsterdam Vodka & Gin, Bacardi Rum, Camarena Silver Tequila, Citrus Sour & Splash of Coca-Cola

Espresso Martini

11

Absolut Vanilla Vodka, Kahlua & Coffee

Hendrick's Peach Refresher

12

Hendrick’s Gin, Peach Puree & Citrus Juices

Coconut Berry Moito

11

Rumhaven Coconut Water Rum, Fresh Lime Juice, Mint & Mixed Berries

Strawberry Lemon Drop Martini

9

Smirnoff Strawberry Vodka, Pink Whitney Vodka & Lemonade, served with a Sweet Sugar Rim & Strawb...

Tavern Rum Punch

11

Malibu Rum, Capitan Morgan Spiced Rum, Myers’s Dark Rum with Tropical Juices

Spiked Cinnamon Apple

10

Ole Smoky Apple Pie Moonshine, Cinnamon, Lemon & Angry Orchard Crisp Apple Cider with a Cinnamon...

AGAVE SPIRIT COCKTAILS

Spicy Cucumber Margarita

11

21 Seeds Cucumber Jalapeño Tequila, Citrus Sour, Fresh Jalapeno with a Tajin Rim

Desert Pear Margarita

11

Camarena Silver Tequila, Desert Pear & Citrus Sour

Ranch Water

12

Milagro Silver Tequila, Soda Water & Fresh Lime Juice

Smoked Grapefruit Paloma

13

Espolon Blanco Tequila & Mezcal Tequila, with Fresh Lime Juice, Grapefruit Soda & Tajin Rim

Berry Fuego

10

21 Seeds Jalapeño Tequila, Blackberry Puree, Ginger Beer & Citrus Sour

Tavern Margarita

9

Sauza Hacienda Tequila, Triple Sec, Fresh Lime Juice, served on the Rocks with a Salt Rim Add...

WINE

WHITES of INTEREST

La Marca Proseco

6oz - $11 / 9oz - $17 / Bottle - $43

Veneto, Italy

Seven Daughters Moscato

6oz - $9 / 9oz - $13.50 / Bottle - $35

Italy

Chloe Pinot Grigio

6oz - $8 / 9oz - $12 / Bottle - $31

Italy

Whitehaven Sauvignon Blanc

6oz - $11 / 9oz - $16.50 / Bottle - $43

New Zealand

Chloe Rose

6oz - $9 / 9oz - $13.50 / Bottle - $35

California

Canyon Road Chardonnay

6oz- $7 / 9 oz - $10.50 / Bottle - $27

Sonoma, California

Kendall-Jackson Chardonnay

6oz - $11 / 9oz - $16.50 / Bottle - $43

Sonoma, California

Chalk Hill Chardonnay

6oz- $13 / 9oz - $19.50 / Bottle - $51

Russian River Valley California

REDS of INTEREST

Rickshaw Pinot Noir

6oz - $8 / 9oz - $12 / Bottle - $31

Sonoma, California

The Seeker Pinot Noir

6oz - $13 / 9oz - $19.50 / Bottle - $51

France

EOS Merlot

6oz - $8 / 9oz - $12 / Bottle - $31

California

Apothic Red Blend

6oz-$9 / 9oz - $13.50 / Bottle - $35

Central Coast California

Tamari Malbec

6oz - $10 / 9oz - $15 / Bottle - $39

Mendoza, Arizona

The Federalist Cabernet Sauvignon

6oz - $10 / 9oz - $15 / Bottle - $39

Napa, California

Louis Martini Cabernet Sauvignon

6oz - $13 / 9oz - $19.50 / Bottle - $51

Sonoma, California

WINE COCKTAILS

Red Sangria

$8

White Sangria

$8

Click Menu Item For Description

PRE-GAME

POW POW SHRIMP

12.75

crispy shrimp and broccoli, tossed in spicy aioli, topped with fresh scallions & toasted sesam...

TOASTED QUESADILLA

12.99

blackened chicken, queso, cheddar jack cheese, black beans, served with pickled jalapeños, f...

TAVERN LOADED CHILI

(B) - 6.95 | (C) - 5.95

beef, red beans, cheddar jack cheese, sour cream & scallions

PRETZEL BITES

9.89

warm salted pretzel bites served with house-made queso

CRISPY MOZZARELLA

9.99

hand-breaded fresh milk mozzarella, lightly fried, served with balsamic marinara sauce

ONION RINGS

7.99

panko-breaded crispy onion rings, served with choice of dipping sauce (ranch, bbq, honey mustard)

SEARED AHI TUNA *

14.99

blackened tuna seared rare over broccoli slaw, drizzled with red dragon sauce & toasted sesa...

SALADS

COBB SALAD

15.49 | ‍396 CALORIES

romaine & iceberg mix, avocado, tomato, chopped bacon, egg & blue cheese crumbles, served with r...

FIESTA CHICKEN SALAD

15.49 | ‍487 CALORIES

grilled bbq chicken, romaine, corn, black beans, tomatoes, tortilla strips & mexi-ranch dressing

Tavern Salad

7.99

romaine & iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, sliced egg, chopped hickory bacon, ham, almonds, choice...

Caeser Salad

7.99

romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons, tossed with asiago Caesar dressing

TACOS OR WRAPS

Shaved Ribeye Taco

14.99

Shaved rib-eye with broccoli slaw, roasted corn salsa, cheddar jack cheese, tomatoes, chili l...

Citrus Grilled Shrimp Tacos

13.95

Citrus grilled shrimp tacos with broccoli slaw, roasted corn salsa, cheddar jack cheese, tomato...

Beer Battered Icelandic Cod Tacos

13.99

Beer battered Icelandic cod tacos with broccoli slaw, roasted corn salsa, cheddar jack cheese, t...

Blackened Chicken Tacos

12.99

Blackened Chicken with broccoli slaw, roasted corn salsa, cheddar jack cheese, tomatoes, chili ...

Blackened Chicken Wrap

12.99

Blackened Chicken with broccoli slaw, roasted corn salsa, cheddar jack cheese, tomatoes, chili l...

Beer Battered Icelandic Cod Wrap

13.99

Beer battered Icelandic Cod Wrap with broccoli slaw, roasted corn salsa, cheddar jack cheese, to...

Citrus Lime Grilled Shrimp Wrap

13.95

Cirtus lime grilled shrimp wrap with broccoli slaw, roasted corn salsa, cheddar jack cheese, tom...

Shaved Ribeye Wrap

14.99

Shaved ribeye with broccoli slaw, roasted corn salsa, cheddar jack cheese, tomatoes, chili lime ...

CRUNCH TIME

Chips & Salsa

7.99

fresh salsa, with crispy tortilla chips

Chips & Queso

9.99

house-made queso, served with crispy tortilla chips

Nachos Deluxe

(L) - 13.99 | (S) - 9.25

Crispy tortilla chips, chili, cheddar jack cheese, queso, pickled jalapenos, tomatoes, scallions...

SPINACH AND ARTICHOKE DIP

10.99

baked and topped with parmesan panko bread crumbs, served with crispy tortilla chips

BBQ CHICKEN NACHOS

(L) - 13.99 | (S) - 9.25

crispy tortilla chips, bbq-glazed, pulled chicken, queso, cheddar jack cheese, bbq sauce, sour c...

ANGUS BURGERS

Two Smashed Beef Patties, Served with One Side

CLASSIC TAVERN BURGER

12.99

$1 of every burger sale goes to support the Independence Fund cheddar jack cheese, leaf lettuc...

MUSHROOM, ONION & SWISS BURGER

13.25

roasted mushrooms & onions, swiss cheese

SMOKEHOUSE BURGER

13.99

hickory bacon, bbq sauce, cheddar jack cheese, thick cut onion rings

DIABLO BURGER

13.50

spicy mayo, pickled jalapeños, pepper jack cheese and onion strings

VEGGIE BURGER

13.50

veggie patty, leaf lettuce, sliced tomato, pickle chips add cheese + $2

BUILD YOUR OWN SALAD - NEW

$11.49

CHOOSE YOUR LEAF BASE

• romaine

• iceberg

• spinach leaves

• spring mix

• romaine & iceberg mix

CHOOSE SIX INGREDIENTS

• american

• cheddar

• jalapeños

• almonds

• avocado slices

• black beans

• roasted corn

• craisins

• cucumbers

• diced tomatoes

• goat cheese

• MANDARIN ORANGES

• pineapple

• queso fresco

• red peppers

• parmesan

• STRAWBERRIES

• walnuts

• aritchoke hearts

• blue cheese crumbles

• goat cheese

• kalamata olives

• hickory bacon

• beets

• carrots

• chinese noodles

• croutons

• sliced egg

• edamame

• GRAPES

• mushrooms

• provolone

• red onions

• shredded jack cheddar

• shredded pepper jack

• tortilla strips

• tomatoes

CHOOSE YOUR DRESSING

• fat free Italian

• thousand island

• house

• caesar

• ranch

• lemon vinaigrette

• asian sesame

• blue cheese

• honey mustard

• balsamic vinaigrette

TOP IT OFF WITH PROTIEN

• grilled salmon (+$6.50)

• citrus shrimp(+$4.75)

• blackened pulled chicken (+$4.10)

• grilled chicken breast (+$4.50)

TAVERN WINGS

SERVED FLASH FIRED, CHARRED or DRY RUBBED

6 Wings

9.99

six wings flash fired, charred or dry rubbed with one of our 9 sauces: Medium, Hot, BBQ, Lemon P...

12 Tavern Wings

17.50

Twelve wings flash fired, charred or dry rubbed with one of our 9 sauces: Medium, Hot, BBQ, Lemo...

HANDHELDS

SERVED WITH ONE SIDE

THE CHICKEN SANDWICH

12.99

grilled or crispy or spicy, with leaf lettuce & sliced tomato, served with dipping sauce

Classic Reuben

13.89

shaved corn beef, sauerkraut, 1000 island dressing, swiss cheese, on marble rye bread

CAROLINA CHEESESTEAK

15.99

thinly shaved ribeye, roasted veggies, provolone cheese, queso, on a hoagie roll.

Turkey Melt

12.95

thinly sliced turkey, grilled onions, swiss cheese on sourdough

SPECIALTIES

Fish and Chips

15.25

beer-battered Icelandic cod & crispy French fries, served with tartar sauce

Cedar Plank Salmon

19.25

chili lime rubbed salmon roasted on a cedar wood plank, served with one side

Chicken Caprese

15.49 | ‍15.49 CALORIES

marinated grilled chicken breasts, melted mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, lemon butter sauce, s...

Power Bowl

14.99

choice of blackened tuna, shrimp or pulled chicken, served with spinach, carrot, cucumber, e...

T&B Chicken

15.49

grilled chicken breasts, bbq sauce, pepper jack cheese, hickory bacon, honey mustard, served wit...

12 OZ. Ribeye

25.85

55-day aged beef char-grilled over an open flame, served with one side

Low Country Shrimp & Grits

17.45

sautéed shrimp, andouille sausage, onions, peppers, tomatoes, cajun sauce & scallions

Chicken Tenders

14.75

hand-breaded & crispy chicken tenders, choice of honey mustard or bbq sauce, served with one...

SIDES

• FRENCH FRIES

• BUTTERED BROCCOLI
(450 CAL. | 3.99)

• CHEESY GRITS

• YELLOW RICE

• GREEN BEANS

• TATER TOTS

• TAVERN CHIPS

• CRISPY BRUSSELS SPROUTS

SWEET FRIES

DESSERTS

Warm Chocolate Chip Cookies

6.99

5 cookies with each order

Brownie A La Mode

6.99

decadent, moist, dark chocolate, rich chocolate brownie & whipped cream

Cheesecake

6.99

New York Style Cheesecake